Questionnaire, detailed analysis, from Page 18 to Page 35
9.6 HEALTH & FITNESS
All responses in this area surrounded the need for improved/ more sports facilities in
Swanage.
Decent all- weather sports facility (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
To build sports leisure centre ( Transport Evening)
Proper size/ full scale indoor swimming pool ( Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
9.7 TRANSPORT
Of the 74 comments relating to transport 44 (59.5%) relate to public transport. The
desire to see a rail link to Wareham ( 26) and an improvement in public transport in
general (14) are the two main themes of response.
Functional and affordable train service to Wareham (Housing Economic
Regeneration Survey)
Direct rail link - more accessibility to Bournemouth / Poole etc (Methodist Church
Mums and Toddlers)
Public transport is improved (Sea Rowing Club)
Buses from Poole & Bournemouth in evening (Miscellaneous)
Non public transport related replies centred on traffic control/ management (10),
pedestrianisation (6) and parking (6).
Traffic flow to south of town without going through main shops (Friends of Durlston)
Traffic free town centre (Purbeck Gazette)
Lower parking prices (E-Mail)
10. DATA ANALYSIS – QUESTION 4
What one thing would improve your quality of life in Swanage?
The most common topic of response to question 4 by far was transport with nearly 1
in 3 comments (106). Following transport, the environment is the most frequently
cited response (almost 1 out of 8 comments or 13.9%) followed by housing and
economy (41 out of 331 responses – 12.4%).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 19
Table 5 – Responses to Question 4 by Topic
Topic Nu mb er of
Comments
% of
Resp onses
CRIME 22 6.6
ENVIRONMENT 46 13.9
HEALTH AND FITNESS 34 10.3
HOUSING & ECONOMY 41 12.4
LOCAL FACILITIES 24 7.3
TOURISM&
ENTERTAINMENT
36 10.9
TRANSPORT 106 32.0
MISCELLANEOUS 22 6.7
TOTAL 331 100%
Key issues for discussion raised from question 4 include:
The need for a sports centre or sports hall (29)
Better public transport (17)
A better bus service (16)
More control and surveillance of anti social behaviour/vandalism (13)
Traffic calming/ management (11)
Problems with litter (11)
Better rail links (to Wareham) (9)
10. 1 CRIME
Crime was not a topic of greatest importance according to the responses that were
collected (see previous subsection) but antisocial behaviour (13) constitutes the main
focus of the comments on the topic.
Control of anti-social behaviour by young people on seafront (Business Economic
Regeneration Survey)
Proper control of the area of the High Street from the quay to the 'Purbeck' pub (the
pub is not a problem; just a geographical reference) which becomes a playground for
yobs and children who ought to be at home from about 9pm each evening. There are
obvious drunken children, foul language, offensive behaviour etc on parade every
evening ..... where are the police? A very few persistent 'pests' need control! ( Purbeck
G azette, 01-Aug-04)
Further comments related to the feeling of safety and the need for a greater police
presence.
A more high profile police presence (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
More police on the beat (Select & Save)
More and better quality policing (Purbeck Society Meeting)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 20
10.2 HOUSING AND ECONOMY
As with previous questions the need for affordable housing was seen as a point of
debate. However the number of comments received (6) was lower than key issues
raised in other areas such as the need for a sports centre ( 29) or public transport
improvements(42).
The next three main responses concerned the local council:
Council to have more say over local issues/ be more independent (5)
Keep council tax down/ reasonable (4)
Council to listen to local people (4)
Council to be more independent and have more say over local issues ( Purbeck
Society Meeting)
Council Tax kept at reasonable level (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
It is perhaps worth mentioning here that 8 of the above 13 comments were all from
the same source i.e. The Purbeck Society Meeting and possibly shows interest by
members in that society in local policy and decision making. Some similar comments
made on an individual basis included;
Not allowing planning permission in built up areas ( Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
That Council Tax be replaced by a fairer system for OAP's and those on fixed income
(Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
To feel that those who are running the town are working together and not against
each other: for the town and for the future (Business Economic Regeneration Survey)
10. 3 ENVIRONMENT
Just under 1 in 4 (23.9%) of responses abou t the environment were on litter reduction
(11) whilst 17.4% were on the need to improve public toilets (8).
Improved litter collection/ receptacles for litter (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
Litter problems improved (League of Friends)
Better quality toilet facilities (Purbeck Society Meeting)
Some respondents went on to suggest ways of improving the litter situation:
Retail premises to CHARGE for plastic bags: reduce plastic litter (Miscellaneous)
Free refuse bins for locals in Cowlease lane (Purbeck Gazette)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 21
Other responses included less noise (4), improvements to the beach (4) and the
banning of jet skis (3).
10. 4 LOCAL FACILITIES
The most popular form of response under local facilities surrounded shopping
facilities; larger/better supermarket (6) and better quality/service by shops (5) as well
as better shopping environment (2).
Larger supermarket: more choice: better brands (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
Shops should open longer hours: not operate like a hobby ( Miscellaneous
Regeneration Survey)
In addition, there were further suggestions on how improvement in local facilities
would result in betterment of the quality of life in the town. Comments included:
More facilities for disabled (Purbeck Society Meeting)
Support local community initiative for imaginative outdoor play area for young
children (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
We cannot register with a dentist in Swanage (Purbeck Gazette)
Support local community initiative for imaginative outdoor play area for young
children (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
10.5 TOURISM AND ENTERTAINMENT
Although the majority of responses centred on general improvements in tourism
provision the Mowlem theatre received a number of specific comments (6).
Replace the Mowlem Centre - it's terrible (Tourist Information Centre)
Mowlem Theatre refurbished (League of Friends)
The comments on the Mowlem should be taken in relative terms. There were only 6
comments on the Mowlem in this question compared to 29 for the need for a sports
centre/hall suggesting that, although improvement to the Mowlem may be desired, it
is not a priority of the majority of people.
Other responses included; Social/evening even ts (4), a marina (3), no marina (2) and
better/more accommodation for tourists (2).
A possible area for development was raised in the MBA students study but received
no comment within the main questionnaire. That was the development of a ‘good
quality tourist [web] site with clear links to all other sites’ . Coupled with this the
students suggested establishing a marketing plan and brand image for Swanage.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 22
10. 6 HEALTH AND FITNESS
As with previous questions there is evidence of demand for a sports centre/hall.
To build sports leisure centre (Transport Evening)
Sports hall for the community (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
A decent light warm weatherproof sports hall (Purbeck Gazette)
There are also some more specific suggestions;
A fully fitted rowing club (Sea Rowing Club)
Full size swimming pool (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
10.7 TRANSPORT
32% of all responses (106 comments) to question 4 referred to transport showing the
possible strength of feeling in the need for improvements in this area. The top 5
responses are detailed in figure 8.
Once again, as can be seen, a great deal of comments relate to public transport (47%
of responses or 50 comments).
Better transport system: want to use the car less (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
Better local transport in the town (Over 60's Club)
Buses need to run all year round and longer hours (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
There are also a few comments on the Sandbanks ferry including;
Sandbanks Ferry - longer operating hours (Business Economic Regeneration Survey)
Cheaper season tickets for ferry: swipe card system for residents / workers: avoid
queues (Miscellaneous)
Finally, some more specific suggestions included:
Traffic Wardens to improve their public image (Business Economic Regeneration
Survey)
A big reduction in the use of cars for journeys of less than 3-4 miles (Purbeck
Gazette)
Cycle track along Valley Road fr om Corfe Castle to Swanage (Corfe Castle Coffee
Morning)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed Bickle. January 2005 23
Figure 8 - Top 5 Transport Responses
17
16
11
9
7
0 2 4 6 8
10 12 14 16 18
B etter public
t ransoprt
Be tter bus ser vice Tr a ffic
ca lming/ management
Be tter rail links Pedestr ianis ation
10.8 PURBECK SOCIETY MEETING
Members of the society took part in focus groups addressing the question; What
would you hope to change in Swanage? Results are detailed below and the emerging
issues are on very much the same lines as in the community questionnaire.
Table 6 -Responses to Question 4 from Purbeck Society Meeting
Number of
comments
% of responses
Traffic and transport 33 30.8
Local facilities 32 29.9
Tourism & housing 16 15.0
Environment 14 13.1
Local Council 8 7.5
Policing 4 3.7
Main items for discussion
â Additional/ better toilet facilities (10)
â Holiday home owners should pay at least full council tax on their 2 nd homes (9)
â Better local bus routes (8)
â Visitor accommodation and houses are not demolished and replaced by flats (7)
â A comprehensive local traffic management plan (7)
11. Data Analysis – Cumulative Totals
The table below shows the cumulative totals for the major subject areas within
questions 2, 3 and 4. (Only subjects that are included in all 3 questions have been
included). We can see from this that transport is seen as the largest issue followed by
tourism & entertainment and housing & economy.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 24
Table 7 – Cumulative Totals for Major Issues
Topi c Number of
Comments
CRIME 74
ENVIRONMENT 238
HEALTH AND FITNESS 95
HOUSING &
ECONOMY
239
LOCAL FACILITIES 187
TOURISM &
ENTERTAINMENT
285
TRANSPORT 367
TOTAL 1485
12. THE WIDER PICTURE
What follows is an attempt to search deeper into some of the trends that emerged from
this evaluation and to help to explain why some of the major discussion points may
have been raised.
12.1 LAW AND ORDER
Relative to other major themes, law and order receives less coverage within the
responses. For example, 6.6% of responses to question 4 relate to crime compared to
32% to transport. This can be explained by an examination of national crime statistics.
Table 8 demonstrates that the most recent crime statistics (Jan-Mar 2003) show there
are approximately 50% fewer offences per 1000 of population in Purbeck than in
England and Wales as a whole. Also, the number of offences in Purbeck has been
steadily falling over this period.
Interestingly, however, in the most recently published Index of Deprivation (2004)
Swanage South is ranked the 13 th most (out of 247,1 being the most and 247 being the
least) deprived area in Dorset in terms of crime iii whilst Swanage North is 39 th . This
would tend to suggest that whilst crime in Purbeck is far lower than the national
average, in Swanage crime is relatively high compared to the rest of Dorset and
indeed Purbeck.
iii This measures the incidence of recorded crime for four major crime themes, representing the occurrence of personal and
material victimisation at a small area level. Burglary (4 recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003), theft (5
recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003, constrained to CDRP level), criminal damage (10 recorded crime
offence types, April 2002-March 2003) and violence (14 recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 5200 25
Table 8 - Crime figures April 2002-March 2003
Source: www.c crimestatistis. co.ku
When crime is mentioned it is often raised in the context of anti-social behaviour,
especially from youths, and the desire for a greater police presence.
Raising awareness of anti-social behaviour, and the misery it can cause
More police to prevent vandalism / unsociable behaviour
The Western Division of the Dorset Police states that the priority for the division is to
reduce crime and disorder by working in partnership with our communities. Part of
this plan involves the introduction of Police Community Support Officers to support
police officers in tackling anti-social behaviour and providing a highly visible,
reassuring police presence. The findings from this research tend, therefore, to support
the local policing strategy and building on this synergy will be possible in the future.
12.2 AFFORDABLE HOUSING
In terms of housing two themes have emerged: the desire to see reductions in the
number of housing conversions and the need for affordable housing.
A first glance at table 9 below would tend to suggest that the need for affordable
housing in Purbeck is maybe not as high as in other parts of Dorset, with only
Weymouth and Portland and Bournemouth having lower average prices.
Table 9 - Average House Prices in Dorset July – September 2004
Region AV PRICE (£)
East Dorset £277,071
West Dorset £238,084
North Dorset £237,548
Poole £237,495
Christc r c hhu £234,658
Purbeck £224,287
Bournemouth £196,524
Weymouth And Portland £179,990
Source: www.bb c.co.uk
Month Number of
Offences in
Purbeck
Offences per
1000 population
Purbeck
Offences per
1000
population
Dorset
Offences per 1000
England/Wales
u poplation
Apr-Jun 2002 689 20.2 23.3 28.9
Jul-Sep 2002 479 17.9 22.5 28.1
Oct-Dec 2002 365 14.7 22.6 27.7
Jan-Mar 2003 662 141. 215. 279.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 26
However, if comparing the Purbeck average of £224,287 to the national regional
averages in table 10 then it becomes more apparent that there is a need for more
affordable housing in Purbeck and Swanage. It is perhaps then an issue for Dorset and
the South West collectively rather than a problem specifically related to Swanage.
Table 10 - Average House Prices in UK
REGION A V PRICE (£) REGION AV PR I C E (£)
Gre a ter London £287,470 Wales £135,162
South East £227,991 No rt h We s t £133,878
South We s t £201,156 Y o rk s & Humber £133,552
East Anglia £174,948 No rt h £123,606
We s t Midlan ds £159,203 No rth e rn Ir el and £112,806
East Midlands £151,405 S c o t l a n d £107,377
Source: www.bb c.co.uk
12.3 TRANSPORT
The need for an improved public transport infrastructure is clearly a key talking point.
Figure 9 demonstrates that Swanage has the largest percentage of car-less households
in Purbeck and by some clear margin, with the exception of Wareham. With more
than 1 in 4 households in Swanage North being without a car the need for improved
public transport, whilst being an issue for Dorset as a whole, is perhaps magnified in
Swanage.
In more rural areas where households are dispersed over large areas the provision of a
comprehensive public transport system is difficult but if, for example, tourism is to be
sustained in Swanage there is a need for a wider choice of transport options as issues
such as parking problems and crowded roads have been raised in this research as
already being problematic. Data shows that over 85% of journeys into Purbeck are
made by private car iv and reaffirms this need. The following is an extract from the
report ‘Making Purbeck Special’ (a strategy for 2002-07) and summarises the
challenges faced.
‘Transport is an issue of national and local concern which affects the lives of
everyone. The predicted future growth in population with easy access to Purbeck and
leisure trips will further add to the traffic volumes in Purbeck unless alternative forms
of transport are provided and promoted. Th e key challenge is to enable people to
enjoy moving around Purbeck safely and without harming the environment, through
an integrated approach encompassing improved management of road traffic and the
provision of a wider choice of transport.’
iv Source: Making Purbeck More Special – A strategy for the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-7.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 5200 27
Figure 9 - % of Households With no Car or Van in Purbeck – 2001
11.06
14.49
9.06 10.51 9.15
15.11
11.66 10.69
26.14
21.15 20.9
6.44 8.47
14.25
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
Ber
e Reg
is
C a st l e
C reec
h B a rr o w
Lang
t on
Lytche
t t Matrav
e rs
Lytchett Minste
r an
d Upton East
Lytchett Minster and Upton West
St.
Ma
r ti n
S wan
a ge
No
rt h
Sw
a nag
e Sout
h
W a re h am
W e st Purbeck
W inf
rith W o o l
Ward
% of Households
Source: ONS 2001 Census
One of the options open to Swanage is of course the re-opening of the Wareham rail
link, closed in 1972. As the quote below suggests there are possible knock on effects
of re-opening the link that relate to other topics covered in this report. For example, if
the rail link brought in more visitors to Swanage would there be sufficient
infrastructures in place such as increased overnight tourist accommodation to cope
with this possible expansion?
The Council is working closely with rail operators through the Purbeck Rail Partnership to
secure the re-opening of the rail link between Wareham and Swanage. This, together with a
park and ride scheme, at Norden, will reduce the number of car journeys, thereby helping the
environment whilst accommodating visitors to the area.
The Purbeck Rail Partnership has been established to facilitate the re-opening of the rail link
between Wareham and Norden. A demand forecast assessment indicated that a considerable
demand exists for the proposed service, and a business plan indicated that a service could
operate at a revenue profit.
There are no ready solutions to the transport issues raised in this research. Strategies
implemented should complement existing initiatives such as the Dorest Action for
Rural Transport (DART) project which aims to help people in rural areas have better
access to employment, education, training and essential services.
12.4 SPORTS CENTRE
Although, Purbeck offers a wide range of opportunities for outdoor recreation v
including, walking, bathing, cycling and sailing (indeed levels of walking, cycling and
riding in Purbeck are higher than the national average) there is a strong indication in
the responses to the questionnaire that there is a demand for a sports centre of some
v Source: Making Purbeck More Special – A strategy for the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-7.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 28
kind in Swanage. This suggests that residents in Swanage regard health and fitness as
an essential aspect in building a sustainable quality life in the town. The 2004 Index
of Deprivation would suggest that in terms of Health vi Swanage is relatively central
compared to the rest of Dorset; although Swanage Herston and Townsend are listed in
the top 30% of the most deprived areas within Dorset.
The positive effects of sports participation to an individual and a community include;
The opportunity to learn new skills and realize potential
Helps in combating physical and mental stress
Helps integration of communities
A vehicle for life-long learning via participation and volunteering
It is worth remembering the number of comments on the need for improvements in
public transport and the statement that 1 in 4 households in Swanage North are car
less. Perhaps the issue is, primarily, a problem of access to sports facilities (such as
the Purbeck Sports Centre in Wareham) rather than a real demand for having a leisure
centre within Swanage. That is not to say that demand for a sports centre should be
dismissed. Indeed, the Purbeck Heritage Committee will encourage opportunities for
leisure and recreation activities in Purbeck which: provide recreational
opportunities close to communities. – Making Purbeck More Special. A strategy for
the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-07.
One possible course of action may be to build partnerships with health or education
services to increase sports/leisure/recreation participation and activities.
vi This identifies areas with relatively high rates of people who die prematurely or whose quality of life is impaired by poor he alth
or who are disabled, across the whole population, years of Potential Life Lost (1997-2001), Comparative Illness and Disability
Ratio (2001), Measures of emergency admissions to hospital (1999-2002) and Adults under 60 suffering from mood or anxiety
disorders (1997-2002).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 29
13. KEY ISSUES FOR DISCUSSION
Based on the amount of comments on each subject area the following are seen as key
issues within the major topic areas of the report.
CRIME
There is a need for a greater police presence
Control of anti-social behaviour
THE ENVIRONMENT
A cleaner Swanage with less litter
Improvements in provision of public toilets
HEALTH AND FITNESS
A sports centre
Improved sports facilities
HOUSING AND THE ECONOMY
More affordable housing
Fewer flats being built/ flat conversions
LOCAL FACILITIES
More quality shops in general and especially supermarkets
TOURISM & ENTERTAINMENT
Improve/ redevelop the Mowlem Theatre complex
Swanage remains a tourist town/ improvements in tourism provision
TRANSPORT
Improved public transport, in particular a rail link to Wareham
Improved traffic flow/ control of traffic
Improved access to services and facilities
14. CONCLUSION
Swanage is undoubtedly a beautiful place to live but faces a series of challenges to
which it must rise, both in the short term and long term to maintain its attraction as a
tourist destination, yet still being able to provide a sustainable economy for its
inhabitants.
There are no easy short term solutions to some of the main concerns of respondents.
For improvements in public transport provision and affordable housing to be made
will require a longer term strategy and concerted efforts between organisations
working in partnerships within Swanage, Purbeck, Dorset and beyond. Other issues
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 30
raised, such as improvements in public toilet facilities and litter collection may be
able to be tackled within a more localised strategy.
This evaluation is a snapshot of opinions at this particular moment in time. At another
date another snapshot may produce a completely different set of issues. It is perhaps
important then that a follow-up study should be conducted at some point in the future
to establish a) to what extent have the issues raised in the plan been tackled? b) are
people still concerned about the same issues?
This rep ort shou ld not stand alone but b e i nteg r ated w i th other sources of
r esear ch that have contributed towa r d s the Swanage Community Plan. Thi s will
then form a soli d ev idenc e ba se to help inf l u ence th e policy and dec i sion maki ng
p r ocess as well as ensuri ng that the ob jectives of the Plan have been met.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 31
APPENDIX 1. ALL ANSWERS BY QUESTIONS AND TOPICS
QUESTION 1. WHAT DO YOU REALLY LIKE ABOUT LIVING OR VISITING SWANAGE?
Topi c Numb er of
responses
SCENARY &
ENVIRONMENT
451
PEOPLE 68
SAFETY 32
SIZE OF TOWN 31
LOCAL
FACILITIES/SERVICES
180
WAY OF LIFE 115
COMMUNITY FEEL &
ATMOSPHERE
41
TOTAL 918
SCENARY & ENVIRONMENT
Sea/coast 103
Countryside 77
Walking opportunities 43
Scenery /views 40
Beach 30
Peace and quiet 24
Beauty 21
Fresh air 20
Location 17
Climate 10
Durlston County Park 8
Nice environment 8
Open spaces 7
Water sports/sailing 5
The downs 5
Wildlife 4
G ardens 3
G reen areas 2
Hills 2
Days park 2
Footpaths 2
Architecture 2
Floral displays 1
Night sky 1
Dorset – Isle of Purbeck 1
Pleasant area 1
Quality of life 1
Nice town with lovely surroundings 1
Can drive along sea front 1
Seafront –pier to beach 1
Unspoilt charm of West Country seaside resort 1
A treasure that needs to be cared for and guarded to secure its future 1
Regional topography 1
The bay: free of building development 1
No neon signs 1
Wooden groins 1
Stone pavements 1
Alleys 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 32
PEOPLE
People 68
SAFETY
Safety 32
SIZE OF TOWN
Small town 31
LOCAL FACILITIES/SERVICES
Health care 26
Clubs/activities 15
Steam railway 13
Small/independent shops 10
Piers 7
Restaurants / pubs 6
Mowlem 6
G ood range of shops 6
Leisure activities 6
Transport links 5
Sufficient shops 5
Access to shops 5
Shops 5
Carnival 4
Arts 4
Local schools 3
Churches 3
Library 3
Entertainment 3
Folk festival 3
Lack of traffic problems 3
Music events 3
Allotment 2
Church activities 2
Fire station 1
Police station 1
Facilities close together 1
Community facilities 1
Leeson House & St George’s School – built on q uality 1
Bandstand 1
Waverly paddle steamer 1
Events held out of summer 1
Freedom Camping Toms Field 1
Places to visit 1
Balance of retail/ leisure/restaurants 1
Post office 1
Fresh fish 1
Market 1
Chocolate shop 1
Bakeries 1
Fish & chip restaurant 1
Shops are very nice 1
Most of the shop staff are friendly 1
Excellent gift shops 1
Purbeck stone 1
Buildings attractive 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 33
Street lights- can see the sky at night 1
Local trades people give good service 1
Marvellous taxi drivers 1
Beach huts 1
Harbour 1
Lights 1
Good facilities 1
V ista pool 1
Arcade 1
Everything one could want within easy walking distance 1
WAY OF LIFE
Pace of life 20
Roots are here 11
Old fashioned 9
Everything 8
Character 6
Traditional seaside town 3
The unspoilt town 3
Balance between town and country life 2
Quaint alleys and historic buildings 1
Timeless quality without traffic congestion and superstore mentality 1
Respect for the old by the young 1
Sense of traditional values and morals 1
Local history 1
Retired to ideal 1
It is unique 1
Way of life 1
Its extra-special quality 1
Need to appreciate what we have here 1
Good place to live in 1
Not over developed 1
G ood mix of ages 1
Not over developed 1
Heaven on earth for me 1
Country life 1
Sheltered environment to raise children 1
There is still a living community with local shops, local people and a character of its own. It is not a
standardised tourist venue with nothing of its own. It's a friendly place to live with its
Usual problems but really it is very safe and has much to offer - local hospital, health centre, schools
and community life 1
Standard of living 1
It's a great place to live but it's being endangered 1
So pleasant, until the summer when traffic is a great problem 1
Stability - moving onwards slowly - staying much the same 1
Family friendly 1
Not overcrowded with seafront hotels 1
Family orientated 1
Town doesn’t 'close down' in the winter 1
An oasis after Bournemouth & Poole 1
Children can have great freedom 1
Reasonably diverse community 1
Seasonal changes in the character of the town 1
Working - all year round community 1
Out of season - convenient, friendly seafront 1
Space compared to London 1
Surreal aspects of the town: Town Hall / monuments from London 1
G ood for our health here 1
Mix of old buildings and architecture 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 34
Mother-in-law' s homemade fruitcake 1
A special place for us - brings together history, scenery, the Railway 1
Artists community 1
Off the beaten track - have to detour to get here 1
Town 1
Ideal for children's outdoor activity tutor 1
Opportunities to serve the community 1
Surrounding villages 1
Old buildings being replaced by smart new ones 1
Chance for young to help older people in community work 1
Can' t afford to live in Swanage 1
Old part of town interesting – artist 1
No through road to the south so speeding through traffic is limited 1
Acceptance that some - not all - young people must look outside Swanage for business / personal 1
development – properties 1
Continuity of place and people 1
I don' t 1
COMMUNITY FEEL & ATMOSPHERE
Community spirit/feel/atmosphere 21
Atmosphere 11
Summer atmosphere 5
Good feel to the town 1
Co-operation of the churches together 1
Not urban 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 35
QUESTION 2. WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CHANGE OR IMPROVE?
CRIME
More police presence 14
Prevent/reduce vandalism 6
Control of anti social behaviour 5
No drinking in public/streets 2
Police time wasting 1
Police allowed to punish immediately 1
Noise late at night 1
Clamp down on illegal parking esp. on sea front 1
Emphasis on real villains not motorists 1
Reduce crime rate 1
HOUSING & THE ECONOMY
Less building flats/ flat co nversions 21
Affordable housing 16
Restrictions on 2 nd homes 5
More employment opportunities 5
Improve appearance of housing 3
Housing priority for locals 3
Keep young people/ families in the town 2
Local, non-seasonal work 2
Stop building or converting homes and businesses into retirement homes 2
Affordable rents for new businesses - or concessions on rates 1
Economic regeneration 1
More choice in affordable workspaces with good facilities 1
Tightening up on businesses that operate from private homes - parking problems 1
Better housing for Swanage young people 1
Housing: lack of council or shared ownership 1
Loss of vitality to town -2 nd homes 1
Attitude of locals towards second homers 1
Thing to encourage the young to stay 1
Second home owners/visitors – tourist tax 1
Second home owners tax reductions 1
Means testing for 2 nd home owners 1
Housing policy/development 1
Housing: flats etc. hotels, accommodation 1
YOUTH FACILITIES
More/better facilities & activities for the youth 19
Better attitude towards children 2
Sell use of the library to youngsters 1
Topi c Numb er of
responses
CRIME 33
HOUSING & ECONOMY 73
YOUTH FACILITIES 29
ENVIRONMENT 152
LOCAL FACILITIES 98
TOURISM 100
HEALTH & FITNESS 27
TRANSPORT 187
TOTAL 699
All responses in this area surrounded the need for improved/ more sports facilities in
Swanage.
Decent all- weather sports facility (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
To build sports leisure centre ( Transport Evening)
Proper size/ full scale indoor swimming pool ( Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
9.7 TRANSPORT
Of the 74 comments relating to transport 44 (59.5%) relate to public transport. The
desire to see a rail link to Wareham ( 26) and an improvement in public transport in
general (14) are the two main themes of response.
Functional and affordable train service to Wareham (Housing Economic
Regeneration Survey)
Direct rail link - more accessibility to Bournemouth / Poole etc (Methodist Church
Mums and Toddlers)
Public transport is improved (Sea Rowing Club)
Buses from Poole & Bournemouth in evening (Miscellaneous)
Non public transport related replies centred on traffic control/ management (10),
pedestrianisation (6) and parking (6).
Traffic flow to south of town without going through main shops (Friends of Durlston)
Traffic free town centre (Purbeck Gazette)
Lower parking prices (E-Mail)
10. DATA ANALYSIS – QUESTION 4
What one thing would improve your quality of life in Swanage?
The most common topic of response to question 4 by far was transport with nearly 1
in 3 comments (106). Following transport, the environment is the most frequently
cited response (almost 1 out of 8 comments or 13.9%) followed by housing and
economy (41 out of 331 responses – 12.4%).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 19
Table 5 – Responses to Question 4 by Topic
Topic Nu mb er of
Comments
% of
Resp onses
CRIME 22 6.6
ENVIRONMENT 46 13.9
HEALTH AND FITNESS 34 10.3
HOUSING & ECONOMY 41 12.4
LOCAL FACILITIES 24 7.3
TOURISM&
ENTERTAINMENT
36 10.9
TRANSPORT 106 32.0
MISCELLANEOUS 22 6.7
TOTAL 331 100%
Key issues for discussion raised from question 4 include:
The need for a sports centre or sports hall (29)
Better public transport (17)
A better bus service (16)
More control and surveillance of anti social behaviour/vandalism (13)
Traffic calming/ management (11)
Problems with litter (11)
Better rail links (to Wareham) (9)
10. 1 CRIME
Crime was not a topic of greatest importance according to the responses that were
collected (see previous subsection) but antisocial behaviour (13) constitutes the main
focus of the comments on the topic.
Control of anti-social behaviour by young people on seafront (Business Economic
Regeneration Survey)
Proper control of the area of the High Street from the quay to the 'Purbeck' pub (the
pub is not a problem; just a geographical reference) which becomes a playground for
yobs and children who ought to be at home from about 9pm each evening. There are
obvious drunken children, foul language, offensive behaviour etc on parade every
evening ..... where are the police? A very few persistent 'pests' need control! ( Purbeck
G azette, 01-Aug-04)
Further comments related to the feeling of safety and the need for a greater police
presence.
A more high profile police presence (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
More police on the beat (Select & Save)
More and better quality policing (Purbeck Society Meeting)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 20
10.2 HOUSING AND ECONOMY
As with previous questions the need for affordable housing was seen as a point of
debate. However the number of comments received (6) was lower than key issues
raised in other areas such as the need for a sports centre ( 29) or public transport
improvements(42).
The next three main responses concerned the local council:
Council to have more say over local issues/ be more independent (5)
Keep council tax down/ reasonable (4)
Council to listen to local people (4)
Council to be more independent and have more say over local issues ( Purbeck
Society Meeting)
Council Tax kept at reasonable level (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
It is perhaps worth mentioning here that 8 of the above 13 comments were all from
the same source i.e. The Purbeck Society Meeting and possibly shows interest by
members in that society in local policy and decision making. Some similar comments
made on an individual basis included;
Not allowing planning permission in built up areas ( Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
That Council Tax be replaced by a fairer system for OAP's and those on fixed income
(Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
To feel that those who are running the town are working together and not against
each other: for the town and for the future (Business Economic Regeneration Survey)
10. 3 ENVIRONMENT
Just under 1 in 4 (23.9%) of responses abou t the environment were on litter reduction
(11) whilst 17.4% were on the need to improve public toilets (8).
Improved litter collection/ receptacles for litter (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
Litter problems improved (League of Friends)
Better quality toilet facilities (Purbeck Society Meeting)
Some respondents went on to suggest ways of improving the litter situation:
Retail premises to CHARGE for plastic bags: reduce plastic litter (Miscellaneous)
Free refuse bins for locals in Cowlease lane (Purbeck Gazette)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 21
Other responses included less noise (4), improvements to the beach (4) and the
banning of jet skis (3).
10. 4 LOCAL FACILITIES
The most popular form of response under local facilities surrounded shopping
facilities; larger/better supermarket (6) and better quality/service by shops (5) as well
as better shopping environment (2).
Larger supermarket: more choice: better brands (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
Shops should open longer hours: not operate like a hobby ( Miscellaneous
Regeneration Survey)
In addition, there were further suggestions on how improvement in local facilities
would result in betterment of the quality of life in the town. Comments included:
More facilities for disabled (Purbeck Society Meeting)
Support local community initiative for imaginative outdoor play area for young
children (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
We cannot register with a dentist in Swanage (Purbeck Gazette)
Support local community initiative for imaginative outdoor play area for young
children (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
10.5 TOURISM AND ENTERTAINMENT
Although the majority of responses centred on general improvements in tourism
provision the Mowlem theatre received a number of specific comments (6).
Replace the Mowlem Centre - it's terrible (Tourist Information Centre)
Mowlem Theatre refurbished (League of Friends)
The comments on the Mowlem should be taken in relative terms. There were only 6
comments on the Mowlem in this question compared to 29 for the need for a sports
centre/hall suggesting that, although improvement to the Mowlem may be desired, it
is not a priority of the majority of people.
Other responses included; Social/evening even ts (4), a marina (3), no marina (2) and
better/more accommodation for tourists (2).
A possible area for development was raised in the MBA students study but received
no comment within the main questionnaire. That was the development of a ‘good
quality tourist [web] site with clear links to all other sites’ . Coupled with this the
students suggested establishing a marketing plan and brand image for Swanage.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 22
10. 6 HEALTH AND FITNESS
As with previous questions there is evidence of demand for a sports centre/hall.
To build sports leisure centre (Transport Evening)
Sports hall for the community (Miscellaneous Regeneration Survey)
A decent light warm weatherproof sports hall (Purbeck Gazette)
There are also some more specific suggestions;
A fully fitted rowing club (Sea Rowing Club)
Full size swimming pool (Housing Economic Regeneration Survey)
10.7 TRANSPORT
32% of all responses (106 comments) to question 4 referred to transport showing the
possible strength of feeling in the need for improvements in this area. The top 5
responses are detailed in figure 8.
Once again, as can be seen, a great deal of comments relate to public transport (47%
of responses or 50 comments).
Better transport system: want to use the car less (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
Better local transport in the town (Over 60's Club)
Buses need to run all year round and longer hours (Housing Economic Regeneration
Survey)
There are also a few comments on the Sandbanks ferry including;
Sandbanks Ferry - longer operating hours (Business Economic Regeneration Survey)
Cheaper season tickets for ferry: swipe card system for residents / workers: avoid
queues (Miscellaneous)
Finally, some more specific suggestions included:
Traffic Wardens to improve their public image (Business Economic Regeneration
Survey)
A big reduction in the use of cars for journeys of less than 3-4 miles (Purbeck
Gazette)
Cycle track along Valley Road fr om Corfe Castle to Swanage (Corfe Castle Coffee
Morning)
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed Bickle. January 2005 23
Figure 8 - Top 5 Transport Responses
17
16
11
9
7
0 2 4 6 8
10 12 14 16 18
B etter public
t ransoprt
Be tter bus ser vice Tr a ffic
ca lming/ management
Be tter rail links Pedestr ianis ation
10.8 PURBECK SOCIETY MEETING
Members of the society took part in focus groups addressing the question; What
would you hope to change in Swanage? Results are detailed below and the emerging
issues are on very much the same lines as in the community questionnaire.
Table 6 -Responses to Question 4 from Purbeck Society Meeting
Number of
comments
% of responses
Traffic and transport 33 30.8
Local facilities 32 29.9
Tourism & housing 16 15.0
Environment 14 13.1
Local Council 8 7.5
Policing 4 3.7
Main items for discussion
â Additional/ better toilet facilities (10)
â Holiday home owners should pay at least full council tax on their 2 nd homes (9)
â Better local bus routes (8)
â Visitor accommodation and houses are not demolished and replaced by flats (7)
â A comprehensive local traffic management plan (7)
11. Data Analysis – Cumulative Totals
The table below shows the cumulative totals for the major subject areas within
questions 2, 3 and 4. (Only subjects that are included in all 3 questions have been
included). We can see from this that transport is seen as the largest issue followed by
tourism & entertainment and housing & economy.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 24
Table 7 – Cumulative Totals for Major Issues
Topi c Number of
Comments
CRIME 74
ENVIRONMENT 238
HEALTH AND FITNESS 95
HOUSING &
ECONOMY
239
LOCAL FACILITIES 187
TOURISM &
ENTERTAINMENT
285
TRANSPORT 367
TOTAL 1485
12. THE WIDER PICTURE
What follows is an attempt to search deeper into some of the trends that emerged from
this evaluation and to help to explain why some of the major discussion points may
have been raised.
12.1 LAW AND ORDER
Relative to other major themes, law and order receives less coverage within the
responses. For example, 6.6% of responses to question 4 relate to crime compared to
32% to transport. This can be explained by an examination of national crime statistics.
Table 8 demonstrates that the most recent crime statistics (Jan-Mar 2003) show there
are approximately 50% fewer offences per 1000 of population in Purbeck than in
England and Wales as a whole. Also, the number of offences in Purbeck has been
steadily falling over this period.
Interestingly, however, in the most recently published Index of Deprivation (2004)
Swanage South is ranked the 13 th most (out of 247,1 being the most and 247 being the
least) deprived area in Dorset in terms of crime iii whilst Swanage North is 39 th . This
would tend to suggest that whilst crime in Purbeck is far lower than the national
average, in Swanage crime is relatively high compared to the rest of Dorset and
indeed Purbeck.
iii This measures the incidence of recorded crime for four major crime themes, representing the occurrence of personal and
material victimisation at a small area level. Burglary (4 recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003), theft (5
recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003, constrained to CDRP level), criminal damage (10 recorded crime
offence types, April 2002-March 2003) and violence (14 recorded crime offence types, April 2002-March 2003).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 5200 25
Table 8 - Crime figures April 2002-March 2003
Source: www.c crimestatistis. co.ku
When crime is mentioned it is often raised in the context of anti-social behaviour,
especially from youths, and the desire for a greater police presence.
Raising awareness of anti-social behaviour, and the misery it can cause
More police to prevent vandalism / unsociable behaviour
The Western Division of the Dorset Police states that the priority for the division is to
reduce crime and disorder by working in partnership with our communities. Part of
this plan involves the introduction of Police Community Support Officers to support
police officers in tackling anti-social behaviour and providing a highly visible,
reassuring police presence. The findings from this research tend, therefore, to support
the local policing strategy and building on this synergy will be possible in the future.
12.2 AFFORDABLE HOUSING
In terms of housing two themes have emerged: the desire to see reductions in the
number of housing conversions and the need for affordable housing.
A first glance at table 9 below would tend to suggest that the need for affordable
housing in Purbeck is maybe not as high as in other parts of Dorset, with only
Weymouth and Portland and Bournemouth having lower average prices.
Table 9 - Average House Prices in Dorset July – September 2004
Region AV PRICE (£)
East Dorset £277,071
West Dorset £238,084
North Dorset £237,548
Poole £237,495
Christc r c hhu £234,658
Purbeck £224,287
Bournemouth £196,524
Weymouth And Portland £179,990
Source: www.bb c.co.uk
Month Number of
Offences in
Purbeck
Offences per
1000 population
Purbeck
Offences per
1000
population
Dorset
Offences per 1000
England/Wales
u poplation
Apr-Jun 2002 689 20.2 23.3 28.9
Jul-Sep 2002 479 17.9 22.5 28.1
Oct-Dec 2002 365 14.7 22.6 27.7
Jan-Mar 2003 662 141. 215. 279.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 26
However, if comparing the Purbeck average of £224,287 to the national regional
averages in table 10 then it becomes more apparent that there is a need for more
affordable housing in Purbeck and Swanage. It is perhaps then an issue for Dorset and
the South West collectively rather than a problem specifically related to Swanage.
Table 10 - Average House Prices in UK
REGION A V PRICE (£) REGION AV PR I C E (£)
Gre a ter London £287,470 Wales £135,162
South East £227,991 No rt h We s t £133,878
South We s t £201,156 Y o rk s & Humber £133,552
East Anglia £174,948 No rt h £123,606
We s t Midlan ds £159,203 No rth e rn Ir el and £112,806
East Midlands £151,405 S c o t l a n d £107,377
Source: www.bb c.co.uk
12.3 TRANSPORT
The need for an improved public transport infrastructure is clearly a key talking point.
Figure 9 demonstrates that Swanage has the largest percentage of car-less households
in Purbeck and by some clear margin, with the exception of Wareham. With more
than 1 in 4 households in Swanage North being without a car the need for improved
public transport, whilst being an issue for Dorset as a whole, is perhaps magnified in
Swanage.
In more rural areas where households are dispersed over large areas the provision of a
comprehensive public transport system is difficult but if, for example, tourism is to be
sustained in Swanage there is a need for a wider choice of transport options as issues
such as parking problems and crowded roads have been raised in this research as
already being problematic. Data shows that over 85% of journeys into Purbeck are
made by private car iv and reaffirms this need. The following is an extract from the
report ‘Making Purbeck Special’ (a strategy for 2002-07) and summarises the
challenges faced.
‘Transport is an issue of national and local concern which affects the lives of
everyone. The predicted future growth in population with easy access to Purbeck and
leisure trips will further add to the traffic volumes in Purbeck unless alternative forms
of transport are provided and promoted. Th e key challenge is to enable people to
enjoy moving around Purbeck safely and without harming the environment, through
an integrated approach encompassing improved management of road traffic and the
provision of a wider choice of transport.’
iv Source: Making Purbeck More Special – A strategy for the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-7.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 5200 27
Figure 9 - % of Households With no Car or Van in Purbeck – 2001
11.06
14.49
9.06 10.51 9.15
15.11
11.66 10.69
26.14
21.15 20.9
6.44 8.47
14.25
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
Ber
e Reg
is
C a st l e
C reec
h B a rr o w
Lang
t on
Lytche
t t Matrav
e rs
Lytchett Minste
r an
d Upton East
Lytchett Minster and Upton West
St.
Ma
r ti n
S wan
a ge
No
rt h
Sw
a nag
e Sout
h
W a re h am
W e st Purbeck
W inf
rith W o o l
Ward
% of Households
Source: ONS 2001 Census
One of the options open to Swanage is of course the re-opening of the Wareham rail
link, closed in 1972. As the quote below suggests there are possible knock on effects
of re-opening the link that relate to other topics covered in this report. For example, if
the rail link brought in more visitors to Swanage would there be sufficient
infrastructures in place such as increased overnight tourist accommodation to cope
with this possible expansion?
The Council is working closely with rail operators through the Purbeck Rail Partnership to
secure the re-opening of the rail link between Wareham and Swanage. This, together with a
park and ride scheme, at Norden, will reduce the number of car journeys, thereby helping the
environment whilst accommodating visitors to the area.
The Purbeck Rail Partnership has been established to facilitate the re-opening of the rail link
between Wareham and Norden. A demand forecast assessment indicated that a considerable
demand exists for the proposed service, and a business plan indicated that a service could
operate at a revenue profit.
There are no ready solutions to the transport issues raised in this research. Strategies
implemented should complement existing initiatives such as the Dorest Action for
Rural Transport (DART) project which aims to help people in rural areas have better
access to employment, education, training and essential services.
12.4 SPORTS CENTRE
Although, Purbeck offers a wide range of opportunities for outdoor recreation v
including, walking, bathing, cycling and sailing (indeed levels of walking, cycling and
riding in Purbeck are higher than the national average) there is a strong indication in
the responses to the questionnaire that there is a demand for a sports centre of some
v Source: Making Purbeck More Special – A strategy for the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-7.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 28
kind in Swanage. This suggests that residents in Swanage regard health and fitness as
an essential aspect in building a sustainable quality life in the town. The 2004 Index
of Deprivation would suggest that in terms of Health vi Swanage is relatively central
compared to the rest of Dorset; although Swanage Herston and Townsend are listed in
the top 30% of the most deprived areas within Dorset.
The positive effects of sports participation to an individual and a community include;
The opportunity to learn new skills and realize potential
Helps in combating physical and mental stress
Helps integration of communities
A vehicle for life-long learning via participation and volunteering
It is worth remembering the number of comments on the need for improvements in
public transport and the statement that 1 in 4 households in Swanage North are car
less. Perhaps the issue is, primarily, a problem of access to sports facilities (such as
the Purbeck Sports Centre in Wareham) rather than a real demand for having a leisure
centre within Swanage. That is not to say that demand for a sports centre should be
dismissed. Indeed, the Purbeck Heritage Committee will encourage opportunities for
leisure and recreation activities in Purbeck which: provide recreational
opportunities close to communities. – Making Purbeck More Special. A strategy for
the Purbeck Heritage Area 2002-07.
One possible course of action may be to build partnerships with health or education
services to increase sports/leisure/recreation participation and activities.
vi This identifies areas with relatively high rates of people who die prematurely or whose quality of life is impaired by poor he alth
or who are disabled, across the whole population, years of Potential Life Lost (1997-2001), Comparative Illness and Disability
Ratio (2001), Measures of emergency admissions to hospital (1999-2002) and Adults under 60 suffering from mood or anxiety
disorders (1997-2002).
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 29
13. KEY ISSUES FOR DISCUSSION
Based on the amount of comments on each subject area the following are seen as key
issues within the major topic areas of the report.
CRIME
There is a need for a greater police presence
Control of anti-social behaviour
THE ENVIRONMENT
A cleaner Swanage with less litter
Improvements in provision of public toilets
HEALTH AND FITNESS
A sports centre
Improved sports facilities
HOUSING AND THE ECONOMY
More affordable housing
Fewer flats being built/ flat conversions
LOCAL FACILITIES
More quality shops in general and especially supermarkets
TOURISM & ENTERTAINMENT
Improve/ redevelop the Mowlem Theatre complex
Swanage remains a tourist town/ improvements in tourism provision
TRANSPORT
Improved public transport, in particular a rail link to Wareham
Improved traffic flow/ control of traffic
Improved access to services and facilities
14. CONCLUSION
Swanage is undoubtedly a beautiful place to live but faces a series of challenges to
which it must rise, both in the short term and long term to maintain its attraction as a
tourist destination, yet still being able to provide a sustainable economy for its
inhabitants.
There are no easy short term solutions to some of the main concerns of respondents.
For improvements in public transport provision and affordable housing to be made
will require a longer term strategy and concerted efforts between organisations
working in partnerships within Swanage, Purbeck, Dorset and beyond. Other issues
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 30
raised, such as improvements in public toilet facilities and litter collection may be
able to be tackled within a more localised strategy.
This evaluation is a snapshot of opinions at this particular moment in time. At another
date another snapshot may produce a completely different set of issues. It is perhaps
important then that a follow-up study should be conducted at some point in the future
to establish a) to what extent have the issues raised in the plan been tackled? b) are
people still concerned about the same issues?
This rep ort shou ld not stand alone but b e i nteg r ated w i th other sources of
r esear ch that have contributed towa r d s the Swanage Community Plan. Thi s will
then form a soli d ev idenc e ba se to help inf l u ence th e policy and dec i sion maki ng
p r ocess as well as ensuri ng that the ob jectives of the Plan have been met.
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 31
APPENDIX 1. ALL ANSWERS BY QUESTIONS AND TOPICS
QUESTION 1. WHAT DO YOU REALLY LIKE ABOUT LIVING OR VISITING SWANAGE?
Topi c Numb er of
responses
SCENARY &
ENVIRONMENT
451
PEOPLE 68
SAFETY 32
SIZE OF TOWN 31
LOCAL
FACILITIES/SERVICES
180
WAY OF LIFE 115
COMMUNITY FEEL &
ATMOSPHERE
41
TOTAL 918
SCENARY & ENVIRONMENT
Sea/coast 103
Countryside 77
Walking opportunities 43
Scenery /views 40
Beach 30
Peace and quiet 24
Beauty 21
Fresh air 20
Location 17
Climate 10
Durlston County Park 8
Nice environment 8
Open spaces 7
Water sports/sailing 5
The downs 5
Wildlife 4
G ardens 3
G reen areas 2
Hills 2
Days park 2
Footpaths 2
Architecture 2
Floral displays 1
Night sky 1
Dorset – Isle of Purbeck 1
Pleasant area 1
Quality of life 1
Nice town with lovely surroundings 1
Can drive along sea front 1
Seafront –pier to beach 1
Unspoilt charm of West Country seaside resort 1
A treasure that needs to be cared for and guarded to secure its future 1
Regional topography 1
The bay: free of building development 1
No neon signs 1
Wooden groins 1
Stone pavements 1
Alleys 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 32
PEOPLE
People 68
SAFETY
Safety 32
SIZE OF TOWN
Small town 31
LOCAL FACILITIES/SERVICES
Health care 26
Clubs/activities 15
Steam railway 13
Small/independent shops 10
Piers 7
Restaurants / pubs 6
Mowlem 6
G ood range of shops 6
Leisure activities 6
Transport links 5
Sufficient shops 5
Access to shops 5
Shops 5
Carnival 4
Arts 4
Local schools 3
Churches 3
Library 3
Entertainment 3
Folk festival 3
Lack of traffic problems 3
Music events 3
Allotment 2
Church activities 2
Fire station 1
Police station 1
Facilities close together 1
Community facilities 1
Leeson House & St George’s School – built on q uality 1
Bandstand 1
Waverly paddle steamer 1
Events held out of summer 1
Freedom Camping Toms Field 1
Places to visit 1
Balance of retail/ leisure/restaurants 1
Post office 1
Fresh fish 1
Market 1
Chocolate shop 1
Bakeries 1
Fish & chip restaurant 1
Shops are very nice 1
Most of the shop staff are friendly 1
Excellent gift shops 1
Purbeck stone 1
Buildings attractive 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 33
Street lights- can see the sky at night 1
Local trades people give good service 1
Marvellous taxi drivers 1
Beach huts 1
Harbour 1
Lights 1
Good facilities 1
V ista pool 1
Arcade 1
Everything one could want within easy walking distance 1
WAY OF LIFE
Pace of life 20
Roots are here 11
Old fashioned 9
Everything 8
Character 6
Traditional seaside town 3
The unspoilt town 3
Balance between town and country life 2
Quaint alleys and historic buildings 1
Timeless quality without traffic congestion and superstore mentality 1
Respect for the old by the young 1
Sense of traditional values and morals 1
Local history 1
Retired to ideal 1
It is unique 1
Way of life 1
Its extra-special quality 1
Need to appreciate what we have here 1
Good place to live in 1
Not over developed 1
G ood mix of ages 1
Not over developed 1
Heaven on earth for me 1
Country life 1
Sheltered environment to raise children 1
There is still a living community with local shops, local people and a character of its own. It is not a
standardised tourist venue with nothing of its own. It's a friendly place to live with its
Usual problems but really it is very safe and has much to offer - local hospital, health centre, schools
and community life 1
Standard of living 1
It's a great place to live but it's being endangered 1
So pleasant, until the summer when traffic is a great problem 1
Stability - moving onwards slowly - staying much the same 1
Family friendly 1
Not overcrowded with seafront hotels 1
Family orientated 1
Town doesn’t 'close down' in the winter 1
An oasis after Bournemouth & Poole 1
Children can have great freedom 1
Reasonably diverse community 1
Seasonal changes in the character of the town 1
Working - all year round community 1
Out of season - convenient, friendly seafront 1
Space compared to London 1
Surreal aspects of the town: Town Hall / monuments from London 1
G ood for our health here 1
Mix of old buildings and architecture 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 34
Mother-in-law' s homemade fruitcake 1
A special place for us - brings together history, scenery, the Railway 1
Artists community 1
Off the beaten track - have to detour to get here 1
Town 1
Ideal for children's outdoor activity tutor 1
Opportunities to serve the community 1
Surrounding villages 1
Old buildings being replaced by smart new ones 1
Chance for young to help older people in community work 1
Can' t afford to live in Swanage 1
Old part of town interesting – artist 1
No through road to the south so speeding through traffic is limited 1
Acceptance that some - not all - young people must look outside Swanage for business / personal 1
development – properties 1
Continuity of place and people 1
I don' t 1
COMMUNITY FEEL & ATMOSPHERE
Community spirit/feel/atmosphere 21
Atmosphere 11
Summer atmosphere 5
Good feel to the town 1
Co-operation of the churches together 1
Not urban 1
The Swanage Community Plan: Help shape the future of Swanage!
Bournemouth University / PACE / Ed B ickle. January 200 5 35
QUESTION 2. WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CHANGE OR IMPROVE?
CRIME
More police presence 14
Prevent/reduce vandalism 6
Control of anti social behaviour 5
No drinking in public/streets 2
Police time wasting 1
Police allowed to punish immediately 1
Noise late at night 1
Clamp down on illegal parking esp. on sea front 1
Emphasis on real villains not motorists 1
Reduce crime rate 1
HOUSING & THE ECONOMY
Less building flats/ flat co nversions 21
Affordable housing 16
Restrictions on 2 nd homes 5
More employment opportunities 5
Improve appearance of housing 3
Housing priority for locals 3
Keep young people/ families in the town 2
Local, non-seasonal work 2
Stop building or converting homes and businesses into retirement homes 2
Affordable rents for new businesses - or concessions on rates 1
Economic regeneration 1
More choice in affordable workspaces with good facilities 1
Tightening up on businesses that operate from private homes - parking problems 1
Better housing for Swanage young people 1
Housing: lack of council or shared ownership 1
Loss of vitality to town -2 nd homes 1
Attitude of locals towards second homers 1
Thing to encourage the young to stay 1
Second home owners/visitors – tourist tax 1
Second home owners tax reductions 1
Means testing for 2 nd home owners 1
Housing policy/development 1
Housing: flats etc. hotels, accommodation 1
YOUTH FACILITIES
More/better facilities & activities for the youth 19
Better attitude towards children 2
Sell use of the library to youngsters 1
Topi c Numb er of
responses
CRIME 33
HOUSING & ECONOMY 73
YOUTH FACILITIES 29
ENVIRONMENT 152
LOCAL FACILITIES 98
TOURISM 100
HEALTH & FITNESS 27
TRANSPORT 187
TOTAL 699
posted by The Postman at 7:47 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home